Pay Transparency Laws Are Revolutionizing Hiring – Here’s How They’re Changing the Game
In recent years, a significant shift has occurred in the way compensation is handled across the U.S., and much of it can be attributed to the growing movement of pay transparency laws. These laws require employers to disclose pay ranges for open positions either in job postings or during the hiring process. While just a handful of states initially led the charge, today the movement is gaining traction across the country and beginning to shape the future of hiring, fairness, and equality in the workforce.
As of now, Washington D.C. and 13 states—California, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nevada, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington—have pay transparency laws in place. Although four of these states—Illinois, Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Vermont—are scheduled to implement their laws next year, the impact is already being felt. New Jersey recently passed its own pay transparency legislation, and if signed into law, the new rules would take effect within months. Additionally, cities like Jersey City (New Jersey), Cincinnati and Toledo (Ohio), and parts of New York—such as New York City, Ithaca, and Westchester County—are also requiring employers to disclose pay information for job openings.
With the passage of these laws, the conversation surrounding pay transparency has reached a boiling point, sparking a nationwide discussion about how workers should be compensated and how much employers should disclose. While only a minority of states have implemented pay transparency laws, their influence has already begun to impact companies across the nation. But how are these laws affecting employers and employees alike?
The Domino Effect: How Pay Transparency is Impacting Employers Nationwide
Even though pay transparency laws only apply to a limited number of states and cities, they are having a far-reaching impact. Multi-state employers, in particular, are finding that it’s easier and more efficient to adopt a uniform pay transparency policy across all locations, even if some of those locations aren’t governed by such laws. This trend is especially prevalent among larger companies or those hiring remote workers.
Sarah Wieselthier, a partner at Fisher Phillips and employment law expert, highlights the practical implications of the state-level differences. She explains, “For multi-state employers, especially those with remote workers, it’s becoming a matter of practicality to comply with the most stringent laws across the board.” For example, Washington state’s law applies to any employer who advertises a position that could be filled by a Washington resident, regardless of where the employer is based. As a result, many employers are opting to include pay transparency in their job postings for consistency and ease of compliance.
The ripple effect of pay transparency is already being felt outside the affected states. Compensation research provider Payscale estimates that nearly one in three U.S. workers will be impacted by pay transparency laws when they look for a job or check job postings in the coming year. The sheer number of states and cities adopting pay transparency measures means that companies across the U.S. are rethinking their hiring practices and adapting to the new expectations of the modern workforce.
The Influence of Gen Z and Millennials
One of the primary driving forces behind the push for pay transparency is the younger generations entering the workforce. Gen Z, who will make up 30% of the U.S. workforce by 2030, has particularly high expectations for transparency and fairness when it comes to pay. According to Payscale’s senior employment counsel, Lulu Seikaly, transparency in pay is not just a “nice-to-have” feature—it’s a must-have for younger employees. These generations value openness and fairness, and they want employers who are willing to be upfront about what they’re willing to pay for a role.
Gen Z’s demand for pay transparency is reshaping the way employers approach their job postings and recruitment strategies. A study by job platform Indeed found that salary-transparent job listings received three times more applications than those that didn’t disclose pay information. “Job seekers today want to know what to expect when it comes to compensation,” says Viral Kadakia, Indeed’s vice president of product. “If companies aren’t transparent, they’re missing out on top talent.”
These findings are particularly significant considering that Gen Z is just beginning to enter the workforce in large numbers, and their preferences will influence hiring practices for decades to come. But the trend is not exclusive to younger generations—Millennials are also making their expectations clear when it comes to pay transparency. These workers, who value authenticity and fairness, are demanding more information upfront during their job search process, and employers who can provide that information are likely to have an edge in attracting the best talent.
Why Pay Transparency Matters for Employers: More Than Just Legal Compliance
As pay transparency laws spread across the country, some employers may initially see them as a legal obligation or a nuisance to comply with. However, the evidence shows that pay transparency is not only beneficial for employees—it can also be good for business.
According to a study from Payscale, companies that embrace pay transparency outperform others in terms of revenue. Specifically, 57% of companies that exceeded their revenue targets in 2023 were more likely to be open about compensation details with their employees. These companies recognize that providing salary information doesn’t just benefit job seekers—it strengthens internal communication and fosters trust between employees and management.
The same study found that the most successful organizations are also more likely to regularly address issues of pay equity, with 71% of top-performing companies actively working to resolve pay disparities within their workforce. These companies are also more proactive in discussing pay with their employees, ensuring that everyone has access to information that explains how their compensation is determined.
Payscale’s research suggests that top-performing companies see pay transparency as a strategic advantage. “It’s not just about compliance—it’s about engaging employees and ensuring they feel valued and fairly compensated,” Wieselthier explains. “When employees understand the reasoning behind pay decisions, they are more likely to stay with the company and contribute to its success.”
Pay Transparency as a Tool for Pay Equity
In addition to benefiting employers and attracting top talent, pay transparency plays a crucial role in promoting pay equity. While there are federal laws in place to prevent wage discrimination based on gender and other protected categories, pay transparency laws offer a tool for workers to ensure they are being paid fairly. These laws help individuals identify and address pay disparities within their own organizations, making it easier for workers to advocate for themselves when they suspect they’re underpaid compared to others in similar roles.
Wieselthier argues that pay transparency laws are a vital step toward achieving pay equity because they allow individuals to see what others in similar positions are earning. “We don’t know if we are being paid equitably until we know what the range is for a job,” she says. Armed with this information, workers can assess whether their compensation aligns with market rates and negotiate for a fairer salary if necessary.
However, transparency doesn’t automatically guarantee equal pay—it’s still up to employers to ensure they are offering competitive and equitable compensation to their employees. Pay transparency simply gives workers the power to hold their employers accountable.
How Pay Transparency Helps Workers Negotiate Fair Salaries
The true power of pay transparency lies in the ability to level the playing field during salary negotiations. By providing job candidates with a pay range upfront, employers are giving them a starting point for discussions about compensation. This transparency helps employees avoid the uncomfortable situation of having to guess or understate their salary expectations during interviews.
Seikaly notes that offering pay ranges in job postings also helps to establish a more realistic and open conversation about compensation expectations. “When we post salary ranges, we’re providing a clear, honest indication of what candidates can expect, but it also empowers them to negotiate based on their qualifications,” Seikaly explains. Job seekers can now make informed decisions about whether to apply for a role based on whether the pay range aligns with their needs and experience.
In addition to negotiating based on the posted pay range, workers can inquire about the specific criteria employers use to decide where someone falls within that range. “Ask the employer how they determine pay and what factors play into the decision-making process,” Seikaly suggests. This approach ensures that job seekers understand what they need to do to reach the upper end of the pay scale and can position themselves as a competitive candidate.
Related: NYC Bans Landlord-Mandated Broker Fees: A Landmark Move for Renters Amid Real Estate Pushback
Pay Transparency’s Future Impact
As more states adopt pay transparency laws, this movement is set to reshape not only hiring practices but also corporate culture in the U.S. The shift toward transparency is already having a profound impact on workplace dynamics, driving greater fairness and accountability, and empowering employees to take control of their compensation.
Employers who adopt pay transparency and engage in fair pay practices are likely to see stronger employee retention, increased job satisfaction, and a more diverse and competitive workforce. On the other hand, companies that resist transparency may find themselves at a disadvantage when it comes to attracting top talent and maintaining a positive employer brand.
The implementation of pay transparency laws represents a significant shift in how compensation is handled across the U.S. While these laws have started as a state-level initiative, they are poised to change the entire hiring landscape. By offering job seekers access to pay ranges and promoting open conversations about compensation, these laws are making the hiring process more transparent, fair, and equitable. The impact of these laws is already being felt, and as the trend continues to grow, pay transparency will likely become the new standard in the workplace.
